Arthur works his jaw for a moment before he responds. This could turn into an even bigger fight than it already is and he doesn't want to do that in public, so he's trying to collect himself and make sure what he says doesn't set Eames off.

"Okay, first of all," he starts, holding out his hand like he's trying to brace Eames for what he's about to say, "I don't think it's really fair for you to be upset with me right now. Second..." he swallows because his pride is about to take a significant blow, "I am glad you told me rather than stringing me along."

God, that was difficult. Now that that trial is over, he sighs and looks away from Eames. "Although I am now questioning the strength of the enchantment on this watch you gave me." He gestures with the arm he's wearing the watch on. "I really thought I was getting lucky tonight."