James starts undoing his coat once the door closes behind him and smiles back at her as he walks in. He won't try to kiss her or anything - not on the clock - but he will privately think to himself she looks very pretty tonight.

"Thanks."

Once he's at the bar, he orders a hot toddy. Just because it's fucking cold out and he needs something to warm his bones. As he does, he slides a package over the counter towards her.

"Got you something."

He may have gone and looked up online what would flatter her coloring the most, but he wanted her to actually like his first (official) present.