Wait, what? That is the exact amount of weird to get him to look up from his paper and - oh God it's a fae. He didn't ask for this aren't they supposed to avoid outcasts anyway wait no he started the conversation this time shit-

While the panic reigns internally, the expressions and response are a literal monotone, "Don't remember shoving Stiles into a closet."

This is not, in fact, a denial. Hashtag inability to lie.